Costco carport or pop up?

[Hoverdave]

Would like some feedback from all you wonderful expert burners.
I have both a Costco brand 10x20 carport and 2 pop up 10x10 canopies. In your experience which do you think is better suited withstand the strong winds on the playa? I am leaning to the carport with additional guy lines in place to keep in place. The pop up types seem pretty flimsy.
Already have both so cost is not a concern, just don't want to haul it all out there and not use it.
Actually thinking the carport will be better than the awning on the RV since I can add the extra hold downs. Not an really an option for the RV awning since it does not have poles.

[FIGJAM]

Easy Up means Easy destroyed, stick to the carport!!!!!!

[Captain Goddammit]

Definitely do not use your RV awning at Burning Man. It has a good chance of being ripped off by wind.
The Costco 10x20 is well proven on the playa, as long as you do a very good job anchoring it.
EZ-ups are generally too light. They can be made to work, but there's no contest here - go with the 10x20.

[Drawingablank]

I agree - Carport all the way.

The Playa is where EZ ups go to die.

RV awnings are also easily destroyed by far less wind than you are likely to encounter on the playa and are very expensive to repair.

[LowePro]

+1 for Carport with support stakes and guyline or ratchet straps.

Pound a 3-4 ft straight rebar at each carport leg, halfway into the playa. Duct tape the exposed rebar to the carport leg liberally.
Then pound candycane rebar stake (or lagbolt stake) at each corner with a guyline or ratchet strap running up to the corner of the carport. Re-tighten throughout the week as needed.

[Chowski]

As long as you have the Carport, use the carport, but I can tell you from experience that ez-ups work almost as well. I've used the same, decent ez-up four years in a row (including 2015's windpocalypse) with no problems at all. I haven't even used guy wires most years - just a 4-foot green T-stake on each corner, then ziptie and duct tape the hell out of it. To really do it up, you can also brace the cross-arms (usually accordion fold) with a piece of wood or a dowel or something and then duct tape all that. Yes. ez-ups are more likely to implode, but they are not certain to, and can last years with no problems.

Same goes for the carport. As long as you've got it death-lashed to something solid in the ground on each leg, guy wires are kinda overkill. The only thing I would recommend is to tape each joint where the parts of the carport connect. A good strong wind can start the whole thing bouncing up and down a bit, and disconnect at the joints leading to failure.

[SnowBlind]

Costco carports are definitely playa proven, I'd highly recommend it over the ez ups.

A work of warning for anchoring the carport. Neighbors of ours had theirs insufficiently secured, and in a storm the carport broke free. It flew thru the air high enough to clear another car port, then started rolling down the playa with big poles pointing in serveral directions.

One person was barely missed by it and other person would have been hit if the carport hadn't been stopped by a van. In the gusts it build up quite some speed, and I have no doubt that it would have seriously injured the people or worse if it hadn't missed them by pure chance.

So when it doubt, err on the side of securing it better.

[Jackass]

It's all fun and games until your careless neighbor's ez-up comes loose and uses it's legs to etch it's name on your newish BMW's doors and hood, or on your head, or your campmate's windshield. That shit can get real hairy real fast...

[Drawingablank]

It's all fun and games until your careless neighbor's ez-up comes loose and uses it's legs to etch it's name on your newish BMW's doors and hood, or on your head, or your campmate's windshield. That shit can get real hairy real fast...

So much this - But it could occur with any shade that is not sufficiently tied down - it is not just limited to ez ups
,

[Jackass]

Yes it can happen with any structure. I used ez up as an example because I've seen it first hand, and it's more than likely one of the most common. It's nothing compared to a carport, scaffolding or a dome...

[AntiM]

I've seen and EZ go through a windshield, a carport go for a stroll, and a dome lift a guy six feet off the ground as he grabbed for it during set up. Anything can go sideways in the wind. Those campers which go on pickup trucks? Take one off the truck and it can be blown over. Eek.

Here's a before and after of a regional center camp structure, which seemed to be very well secured, and used no shit rebar and straps:

023 - Copy.JPG

048 - Copy.JPG

[Captain Goddammit]

So I gather you want to avoid a pink center on a shade structure then.

[AntiM]

So I gather you want to avoid a pink center on a shade structure then.

I think Nipples R Us can get away with it.