No more dogs or cats in california

All things outside of Burning Man.
can't sit still
Posts: 4645
Joined: Tue Aug 23, 2005 4:21 pm
Location: SoCal

No more dogs or cats in california

Post by can't sit still » Wed Jul 18, 2007 11:58 am

Just in case you missed it, PETA is trying to get rid of all dogs and cats in Ca. http://www.akc.org/canine_legislation/C ... center.cfm
You have to wonder about the mentality of a group that would prefer extinction of a species rather than subject a small % of them to abuse. Dogs and cats were just the start. They were lining up on birds and planning on horses.
There weren't any practical exemptions. Their oposition came from several areas including the DEA and Homeland Security. They said that they would lose decades of breeding lines of smart drug sniffing dogs.
Levine, who authored the bill has a PETA member for a SO. He's the worst kind of grandstanding politician. He pushed through some kind of legislation requiring zoos to walk their elephants 5 miles a day. The LA zoo got rid of their elephants [this is unsubstantiated hearsay,,to me]
The avowed plan is to have the pets die out in 10 years and not be replaced. Like the shithead gun control people, they attack the law abiding people because they can't affect the real problem.
Just think, a new cadre of "Pet Police" to punish humans who oppose the extinction of animals. PETAs new slogan could be "Extinction is Salvation"
Dan
I don't post things because I believe that they are the absolute truth. I post them because I believe that they should be considered.

User avatar
AntiM
Moderator
Posts: 20301
Joined: Wed Mar 24, 2004 5:23 am
Burning Since: 2001
Camp Name: Anti M's Home for Wayward Art
Location: Wild, Wild West

Post by AntiM » Wed Jul 18, 2007 12:36 pm

Peta kills homeless animals. I mean, WTF?! I have zero respect for them anymore. Hypocrites who suck in the soft-hearted.

User avatar
Isotopia
Posts: 2848
Joined: Fri Sep 05, 2003 11:26 am

Post by Isotopia » Wed Jul 18, 2007 1:07 pm

I'm assuming you saw this Penn and Teller episode of http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=l9ijLulwUTY
Bullshit
?

User avatar
AntiM
Moderator
Posts: 20301
Joined: Wed Mar 24, 2004 5:23 am
Burning Since: 2001
Camp Name: Anti M's Home for Wayward Art
Location: Wild, Wild West

Post by AntiM » Wed Jul 18, 2007 1:13 pm

bingo. Guess who lent it to me?

User avatar
Dork
Posts: 2065
Joined: Tue Jan 06, 2004 6:01 pm
Location: Las Vegas

Post by Dork » Wed Jul 18, 2007 1:33 pm

The law wouldn't outlaw pets and wouldn't cause them to become extinct. There would still be PLENTY of unwanted animals being born, and millions available in other states. It's also not about the small % of them who get abused - it's about the large percentage who get killed in shelters because nobody wants them, or die on the streets because they're abandoned. Valuable breeding lines would do just fine - the breeders would simply need to get permits. If you look at the bill, the regulations are pretty lax about who can get a permit.

I'm not saying I would support the bill, but if you're going to come out against it at least try to be rational. There are plenty of ways to bash PETA using actual facts.

Archantael
Posts: 472
Joined: Tue Oct 14, 2003 10:29 pm

Post by Archantael » Wed Jul 18, 2007 1:39 pm

Asking someone to be rational when dealing with PETA is asking for defeat and to have their agenda rammed down your throat.

User avatar
LeChatNoir
Posts: 5907
Joined: Mon Sep 01, 2003 8:52 am
Location: Louisville, Ky

Post by LeChatNoir » Wed Jul 18, 2007 1:41 pm

Looks like that legislation got beaten down. I'm no fan of PETA and I don't believe in legislation being the answer to all problems.

The problem this was approaching, however I know very keenly. Shelters and Humane Societies across the US, one of which I volunteer at, kill collectively 1000s of animals a year, via vet performed euthanization, because there simply is no room for, and money to feed, them all. These are volunteer run groups who are funded by donations and personal money from their members. Budgets are pretty small and when there is no money, there is no money.

So I propose a better approach...

Fund a spay/neuter at your local shelter or Humane Society. I can help you find a humane society group in your area (or mine!!!) so that you may do that, if you wish. Just send me a PM.
The New and Improved Black Cat... now with 25% more blather

User avatar
Isotopia
Posts: 2848
Joined: Fri Sep 05, 2003 11:26 am

Post by Isotopia » Wed Jul 18, 2007 1:56 pm

Is it wrong of me to suggest that if the bill were worded to specifically target adults of breeding age that I'd be totally in favor of it?

User avatar
joel the ornery
Posts: 2657
Joined: Sun Aug 31, 2003 3:28 pm
Burning Since: 1998
Location: i'm the snarky one in your worst fucking nightmares
Contact:

Post by joel the ornery » Wed Jul 18, 2007 2:07 pm

Isotopia wrote:Is it wrong of me to suggest that if the bill were worded to specifically target adults of breeding age that I'd be totally in favor of it?
nope, i'd agree with that requirement.

MozyBonz
Posts: 3429
Joined: Mon Feb 19, 2007 8:54 pm

Post by MozyBonz » Wed Jul 18, 2007 2:19 pm

All of our animal family members have been rescues. Not PETA style
Just no one wanted them... a dog left in a box at friends house. A Great Dane that got to big for the family.
Cat that has diabetes and needs shots 2 times a day. Bird’s people
Couldn’t stand hearing any more. A dragon that started biting kids.

The latest a six-week-old cat found in a parking lot far from any home infested with flees.

Now all have chips, tags, fixed or will be fixed also regular trips to the veterinary.

Fuck PETA my dogs and I love meat.



--------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Isotopia wrote:
Is it wrong of me to suggest that if the bill were worded to specifically target adults of breeding age that I'd be totally in favor of it?


nope, i'd agree with that requirement.

I think China does that now. "Chinese birth control and One Child policy"

Media mogul Ted Turner has suggested the rest of the world
Adopt similar policies.

User avatar
Dork
Posts: 2065
Joined: Tue Jan 06, 2004 6:01 pm
Location: Las Vegas

Post by Dork » Wed Jul 18, 2007 2:21 pm

Archantael wrote:Asking someone to be rational when dealing with PETA is asking for defeat and to have their agenda rammed down your throat.
True, but I still get riled up when I see people try to fight bullshit with even thicker bullshit. Unfortunately, it's a growing trend in our society. There is less and less room for rational argument on anything these days.

User avatar
AntiM
Moderator
Posts: 20301
Joined: Wed Mar 24, 2004 5:23 am
Burning Since: 2001
Camp Name: Anti M's Home for Wayward Art
Location: Wild, Wild West

Post by AntiM » Wed Jul 18, 2007 2:52 pm

The mandatory spay and neuter would be a good idea if it could be enforced. Heck, I've been fixed.

User avatar
LeChatNoir
Posts: 5907
Joined: Mon Sep 01, 2003 8:52 am
Location: Louisville, Ky

Post by LeChatNoir » Wed Jul 18, 2007 3:23 pm

Isotopia wrote:Is it wrong of me to suggest that if the bill were worded to specifically target adults of breeding age that I'd be totally in favor of it?
Reminds me of a song that I can never remember the name of, or the band that sings it, and yet it stays there in my head... Green Day maybe?

"I've been around the world and found that only stupid people are breeding..."
The New and Improved Black Cat... now with 25% more blather

User avatar
LeChatNoir
Posts: 5907
Joined: Mon Sep 01, 2003 8:52 am
Location: Louisville, Ky

Post by LeChatNoir » Wed Jul 18, 2007 3:24 pm

MozyBonz wrote:All of our animal family members have been rescues. Not PETA style
Just no one wanted them... a dog left in a box at friends house. A Great Dane that got to big for the family.
Cat that has diabetes and needs shots 2 times a day. Bird’s people
Couldn’t stand hearing any more. A dragon that started biting kids.

The latest a six-week-old cat found in a parking lot far from any home infested with flees...
Thanks, Mozy.
The New and Improved Black Cat... now with 25% more blather

User avatar
capjbadger
Posts: 2691
Joined: Sun Jun 19, 2005 1:17 am
Burning Since: 2005
Camp Name: Lamplighters
Location: Horus' Left Armpit

Post by capjbadger » Wed Jul 18, 2007 4:44 pm

LeChatNoir wrote:
Isotopia wrote:Is it wrong of me to suggest that if the bill were worded to specifically target adults of breeding age that I'd be totally in favor of it?
Reminds me of a song that I can never remember the name of, or the band that sings it, and yet it stays there in my head... Green Day maybe?

"I've been around the world and found that only stupid people are breeding..."
Flagpole Sitter by Harvey Danger

I had visions, I was in them
I was looking into the mirror
To see a little bit clearer
Rottenness and evil in me

Fingertips have memories
Mine can't forget the curves of your body
And when I feel a bit naughty
I run it up the flagpole and see who salutes
(but no one ever does)

I'm not sick but I'm not well
And I'm so hot cause I'm in hell

Been around the world and found
That only stupid people are breeding
The cretins cloning and feeding
And I don't even own a tv

Put me in the hospital for nerves
And then they had to commit me
You told them all I was crazy
They cut off my legs now i'm an amputee, God damn you

I'm not sick but I'm not well
And I'm so hot cause I'm in hell
I'm not sick but I'm not well
And it's a sin to live so well

I wanna publish zines
And rage against machines
I wanna pierce my tongue
It doesn't hurt, it feels fine
The trivial sublime
I'd like to turn off time
And kill my mind
You kill my mind

Paranoia! Paranoia!
Everybody's coming to get me
Just say you never met me
I'm going underground with the moles
Hear the voices in my head
I swear to God it sounds like they're snoring
But if you're bored then you're boring
The agony and the irony, they' re killing me

I'm not sick but I'm not well
And I'm so hot cause I'm in hell
I'm not sick but I'm not well
And it's a sin to live so well
Arrrggg!! Avast ye fucking fluffy bunny shirtcockers! Haul your drunken hairy fat ass out of our sight or prepare to receive a hot buttered hedgehog fired up your aft quarters!

Honey Badger don't care. Honey Badger don't give a shit!

can't sit still
Posts: 4645
Joined: Tue Aug 23, 2005 4:21 pm
Location: SoCal

Post by can't sit still » Wed Jul 18, 2007 5:24 pm

The question at the bottom of everything is ethics. Unwanted animals are left to the "street" If they're picked up, they're often euthanised.
Unwanted humans are left to the street. This includes children,,, read about Brazil. There are do-it-yourself euthanasia clinics in Britian.

The age-old question; why come into the world if you're just going to die? Is there a difference between dying young or dying old? Is it purely hedonistic? Euthanasia for animals is sad but why should it be considered cruel? Starvation and dementia are cruel. Endless pain is cruel. Why should euthanasia be considered cruel? I watched my mother survive on a morphine pump. If she were euthanised at the start, would that have been cruel?,,, struck by lightning?
Kevorkian tried to bring these questions to the table.Nobody wanted to address them.
Do you support life for an organism as long as it's productive?,, viable?,,, living? I shot my neighbor's cat through the head. It had just been run over by a car and was crushed from the lungs back.
It's hard to choose criteria. Should you euthanise an organism if it has no possibility of a healthy future? If you apply these criteria to other organisms,,,, should you apply them to man?
Do you apply "healthy" to man and "useful" to animals? Old organisms are generally cast aside. Many people, after touring a geriatric home, are horrified at that prospect for their own personal future.
IS EUTHANASIA BETTER THAN DRAGGING OUT EVERY LAST PAINFUL MOMENT OF LIFE ? It's not an easy answer for Fido or Larry H.
It appears that PETA wants to reconstruct the original food chain. The mice will get eaten by an owl instead of dying in the lab. How very benevolent.
I don't post things because I believe that they are the absolute truth. I post them because I believe that they should be considered.

User avatar
LeChatNoir
Posts: 5907
Joined: Mon Sep 01, 2003 8:52 am
Location: Louisville, Ky

Post by LeChatNoir » Wed Jul 18, 2007 8:06 pm

can't sit still wrote:Euthanasia for animals is sad but why should it be considered cruel?
What I was talking about has nothing to do with old animals. These are young kittens and puppies. It's cruel because it is so unecessary... and due to fact that so many people do nothing and think its not their problem.
The New and Improved Black Cat... now with 25% more blather

User avatar
Ugly Dougly
Posts: 17612
Joined: Wed Sep 10, 2003 9:31 am
Burning Since: 1996
Location: เชียงใหม่

Post by Ugly Dougly » Thu Jul 19, 2007 8:57 am

Unregistered and unspayed cats and dogs are coming into California over the Mexican border.

MozyBonz
Posts: 3429
Joined: Mon Feb 19, 2007 8:54 pm

Post by MozyBonz » Thu Jul 19, 2007 9:05 am

Ugly Dougly wrote:Unregistered and unspayed cats and dogs are coming into California over the Mexican border.
Oh Come on ugly cats are swimming across the Rio Grand River?

I can see the dogs but the cats?

they must really need work...

User avatar
joel the ornery
Posts: 2657
Joined: Sun Aug 31, 2003 3:28 pm
Burning Since: 1998
Location: i'm the snarky one in your worst fucking nightmares
Contact:

Post by joel the ornery » Thu Jul 19, 2007 9:58 am

AntiM wrote:Heck, I've been fixed.
ITYM: I've got a sports model, now

can't sit still
Posts: 4645
Joined: Tue Aug 23, 2005 4:21 pm
Location: SoCal

Post by can't sit still » Thu Aug 13, 2009 7:26 pm

This came in mail from a friend. I couldn't get the graphs to copy.

From: Concerned Dog Owners of California <update>
Date: August 13, 2009 2:47:38 PM PDT
To: [email protected]
Subject: LETTERS TO SACRAMENTO
Reply-To: [email protected]


Concerned Dog Owners of California

August 13, 2009

LEGISLATURE RESUMES ON AUGUST 17th
Easy way to do letters!


FLOREZ COMMITTED TO SB250
Budget, Dead Dogs and Disadvantaged Not An Issue For Him

The Legislature will reconvene on Monday, August 16th and Florez has made it clear that his commitments to the Animal Rights people will trump any other concerns. He is determined to get the bill out of Appropriations and onto the Floor.

So it is time for us to get more letters to the Assembly Members. And we need letters not just from all of you (again), but from your family members, friends and associates who are registered voters in California.

To make this easy we have put together a special page that has all the information you and they need including the link to the Save Our Dogs page where they can do the letter in less than one minute. You can get to this page by

clicking here

By going to the CDOC website. Go to the Get Involved page where you'll find "Send A Letter".

Please send this link to your Clubs, your friends, and add it to your own website. These letters Assembly Members from their constituent is the most powerful tool we have.


Judie needs moneyjmlogo

She has asked all of her supporters her $25 to help make sure that SB250 is passed this year; she even had time to have a cute little logo done. I guess when she gave that $20,000 to Senator Steinberg, she left herself a little short.

Interestingly, $25 is about what is costs to produce each of the 48 page color booklets that CDOC provides to each member of the Legislature both in Sacramento and their Districts about why SB250 is so devastating. We are also sending the books to Mayors and Council people across California so they can see the financial burden that Senator Florez has in store for them.

So we are issuing our own challenge. $25 to defeat SB250.

We don't have a logo but click here to donate $25.00 for printed materials to Oppose SB250. And then look for your name on our Supporters Page. Let's make sure everyone in California knows just how bad this bill can be.

If there was any doubt about how many more dogs will die if SB250 passes, the City of Los Angeles has resolved those for us.





The proponents would say that this 24% increase - owned dogs that were killed by the City - was due to the economy. But when you look at counties with worse economies, more poverty and higher foreclosure rates, you see that there is one thing that is different about the City of Los Angeles. Mandatory Spay and Neuter. And who brought that to us? Judie Mancuso.

YOU NEED TO

Get the this page out to all of your friends and associates so they will get letters off the Assembly Members.

So make your contribution to Defeat SB250 here. With the help of Save Our Dogs and there letter writing system, we'll get the word to everyone!

PLEASE CROSSPOST

Finally, thank you for all your positive comments about how much easier it is to find things on the website now. We appreciate it.
DID YOU KNOW?

Did you know, that veterinarians recommend that you don't get a rabies shot for your dog until it is four months of age. But did you know that if your dog is not licensed (any type) by the time your dog is four months of age, when you go to get your license, unless you arrange to get both your rabies vaccination and license on the exact day your dog is 4 months of age, you will, under SB250, be guilty of having an unlicensed dog. And of course that means you must sterilize all the dogs you own and you cannot ever own an intact dogs again.

Did you know, that Councilwoman Gomes from Vallejo was a witness for Senator Florez claiming that the bankrupt City would save $750,000 if only SB250 was passed because that is what they spend housing and euthanizing dogs. But did you know that the actual number spent on taking in dogs is only $150,000; the rest us spent on other animal control functions not affected by SB250.

And did you know, that 49 separate AKC events held in Vallejo in 2008 generated $2,069,802 just in participant spending - this does not include money spent to put on the dog show. Since the Councilwoman wants to trade over $2,000,000 in annual income for a bet that she might save, over time, $150,000, it is not a secret why Vallejo is the only city on the state to declare bankruptcy!

PERMISSION TO CROSSPOST

huntingdogs MORE INFORMATION NEEDED

Check to see if your Club has sent their information!

CDOC has taken all the dog show events in the State of California, determined (using the AKC formula) how much is spent in hotels, food and fuel by participants at each one. We have combined them by Assembly Member (and Senator) so we can tell each Member what events bring to their Community.

But we know participant spending is only one part of the equation. So we are asking each entity that puts on an event - conformation, obedience, rally, agility, lure coursing, earth dog event, field trial, hunt test, etc. what they are spending to put on the event.

Please get this request to whomever in your Club has the numbers for 2008 and ask them to email to [email protected] with the following:

Tenting
Facility Rental
Flowers
Catering
Judges Food
Hotel Rooms for Judges
Local Advertising
Parking revenues generated for local groups
Local transportation (judges to/from airport, etc)
On site personnel hired
Security hired

There were 1621 individual events (just AKC events; doesn't include other events although we would like to have this information for everything) held in California in 2008. We are making phone calls but if you will make sure your Club or organization gets this email and if you will follow up to see that they send the information, we will be able to get this out more quickly. And time is critical!

PLEASE CROSSPOST


ChamberREPUBLICANS OPPOSE SB250
When you are sending your letters and educational materials to the Appropriations Committee, please do not bother to send them to the five Republicans (Nielsen, Strickland, Harkey, Duvall and Miller). They are with us on this. They know the legislation will kill more dogs, especially those owned by poorer people and those not well educated.
So please focus on the Democrats as you are sending your faxes and scheduling your meetings. In this case, it is the Republicans who are for the economically disadvantaged.
PLEASE CROSS POST
DVD Cover FUND RAISER FOR CDOC ACTION
Handling Secrets Uncovered

The proceeds from the sale of Handling Secrets Uncovered are going into CDOC Action - our lobbying and legal affiliate. These monies will be used toRightinsde pursue our litigation against the City of Los Angeles and we will build a fund available in California and across the United States to oppose legislation that is bad for the health of dogs and restricts the rights of responsible dog owners. We believe educational presentations like this are an excellent way to make sure that, as a community of dog people, we have the funds we need to opposed radical animal rights groups. We thank you for your participation and support.

Please order your copy here.
I don't post things because I believe that they are the absolute truth. I post them because I believe that they should be considered.

User avatar
Glittering Clitoris
Posts: 128
Joined: Thu Jun 10, 2004 10:09 pm
Location: Seattle

Post by Glittering Clitoris » Thu Aug 13, 2009 7:46 pm

I say we call them "Land Fish"

then eat them
I BURN for YOU!

can't sit still
Posts: 4645
Joined: Tue Aug 23, 2005 4:21 pm
Location: SoCal

Post by can't sit still » Thu Aug 13, 2009 8:06 pm

Ms Glittering Clitoris, nice of you to drop by. That was an impressive video that you posted. You are the master of mastering the "gag reflex"
Yes, we could call them 'Land Fish" It's been done before.
Nutritionists tried to import linseed oil for human consumption. They were refused entry of their product. So, they just called it "flaxseed oil" and it was allowed.
I don't have a personal stake in the mandatory spay law. I was just passing on the info for a friend that I have known since she was 12.

My friend Kathy just sent this reply after she read the thread here;

Wow, That was interesting! I went on and read everything. You should tell the people to go to ExposeAnimalRights.com then they can read the real truth about the difference between Animal Rights vs Animal Welfare. It is hard to tell the difference between the two since Wayne Pacelle (HSUS) is a professional liar. HSUS is actually worse than PETA, they are more believable than Peta, but have the same agenda, just more subtle with more money and power. We call them PETA in Suits
Kathy
I don't post things because I believe that they are the absolute truth. I post them because I believe that they should be considered.

Oldguy
Posts: 1533
Joined: Sun May 07, 2006 12:22 am
Burning Since: 2005
Location: LiveOak Cal

Post by Oldguy » Thu Aug 13, 2009 9:06 pm

FWIW, My dog license for a spayed female is $15.00 for three years. When I turn 60, it goes down to $10.00 for three years. I don't think she'll live to be 14 so $25 to keep her for six more years is quite resonable for my counties animal control. I got my puppy at the pound and had her spayed when she was old enough. The $40.00 adoption fee was refundable with spaying. So I'm out the cost of kibble and shots to keep a companion animal who wakes me in the morning, lets me know when the mailman passes by, and is a great burglar/stranger alarm. The real problem in this country is irresponsible pet owners. Adopt a pound puppy.

BTW, I hear Vick is going to the Eagles.

User avatar
Glittering Clitoris
Posts: 128
Joined: Thu Jun 10, 2004 10:09 pm
Location: Seattle

Post by Glittering Clitoris » Thu Aug 13, 2009 9:10 pm

What "Gag reflex"?

was cuming out of her nose!



Glit Clit
I BURN for YOU!

User avatar
gyre
Posts: 15457
Joined: Sun Aug 07, 2005 6:01 pm
Location: ΦάÏ

Post by gyre » Fri Aug 14, 2009 12:53 am

Did everyone catch the peta protest about the fly death during the Obama interview?

They sent him a no-kill fly trap.

Those guys are pure performance theater.
I hear three stooges theme music whenever they show up.

User avatar
Apollonaris Zeus
Posts: 3716
Joined: Sun Sep 14, 2003 11:17 am

Post by Apollonaris Zeus » Fri Aug 14, 2009 8:38 am

gyre wrote:Did everyone catch the peta protest about the fly death during the Obama interview?

They sent him a no-kill fly trap.
I am a member and we are going to preserve and protect the Anopheles Mosquito with suppling little babies so they can feed and multiple the earth!

We are presently seeking hosts.

Will you donate your offspring?

Have a dead parent lying around?
We have a fly breeding program as well.

Our flies are hungry!

User avatar
Ugly Dougly
Posts: 17612
Joined: Wed Sep 10, 2003 9:31 am
Burning Since: 1996
Location: เชียงใหม่

Post by Ugly Dougly » Fri Aug 14, 2009 9:22 am

Please think of the rats.

The noble rat (Rattus norvegicus) is today facing unprecedented threats to its habitat. Professional "exterminators" think of nothing better than to kill these poor misunderstood mammals. I blame PETA and all those damn hippies.

can't sit still
Posts: 4645
Joined: Tue Aug 23, 2005 4:21 pm
Location: SoCal

Post by can't sit still » Fri Aug 14, 2009 4:40 pm

dougly, I have to disagree. Like man, the Norway rat can make any habitat his home. At one time rats ate 10 % of the food supply in India so, I don't think that they will be wiped out any time soon. Cuba has invented a rat poison that gives rat-salmonella to,,, rats. If any other animal eats it, it doesn't affect them.
Bush said that it's useless here,,, we don't have a rat problem in the U.S.

Ms Clitorus, yes indeed, it was cumming out your nose. No gag and no sneeze either. Remarkable. All us boys are envious of your partner.
I don't post things because I believe that they are the absolute truth. I post them because I believe that they should be considered.

User avatar
unjonharley
Posts: 10434
Joined: Tue Sep 09, 2003 11:05 am
Burning Since: 2001
Camp Name: Elliot's naked bycycel repair
Location: Salem Or.

Post by unjonharley » Fri Aug 14, 2009 6:21 pm

can't sit still wrote:dougly, I have to disagree. Like man, the Norway rat can make any habitat his home. At one time rats ate 10 % of the food supply in India so, I don't think that they will be wiped out any time soon. Cuba has invented a rat poison that gives rat-salmonella to,,, rats. If any other animal eats it, it doesn't affect them.
Bush said that it's useless here,,, we don't have a rat problem in the U.S.

what do you exspect from the king rat himself.

unloaded a house after a fire. there were norway rafter rats in the dresses and end tables. chased rats for 6 months in the shop. this was a mayors house.

Post Reply

Return to “Open Discussion”