I always have trouble with that statement:jkisha wrote:There are several things in the proposal I don't like either. Like I said earlier, everybody will have something not to like in this proposal.can't sit still wrote:jk, it's great that you're thinking about this stuff. I see a couple of things in the proposal that I don't like;
"cost of U. S. engagement in Afghanistan and Iraq will decrease significantly by 2020."
I just can't see any justification to be in these wars. What is the objective? What have we changed?
"manual-labor-intensive jobs and would therefore find working past sixty-seven an undue burden"
That means that me and ygmir will still be breaking down tires and digging ditches when we're 66 y.o.![]()
The current COLA does not take into account the cost of energy. Obummer says that carbon tax is going to cause the cost of energy "skyrocket"
"At current spending levels, Social Security is projected to become insolvent by 2037"
Last month SS payed out more than it took in. It holds $ 7.4 trillion in non-negotiable treasury bonds. I seriously doubt that treasury will find the money to fund both SS and Medicare. The unfunded liabilities stand at about $ 112 trillion.
Our current debt by GAP standards is about 860 % of GDP.
"Projected Debt-to-GDP Ratio in 2020: 52%"
This is pie-in-the-sky projections that don't take all the liabilities into account.
I'm glad that they're thinking about it. David Walker, the recently departed U.S. Comptroller-General said that there is NO way out. We'll see.
I'm not up on all of the figures, so I won't try to argue those points with you except to say that my understanding differs from your figures on Social Security and Medicare and some of your other predictions.
I do agree with you on both Iraq and Afghanistan--no reason to be there. Is your argument being we should end those two wars and cut military budget even more than proposed? If so, that is not even close to what the current reality dictates. It will be hard enough to get congress to agree on ANY military cuts, let alone the comparatively gigantic cuts in the proposal. Try and remember the last time the military budget was cut.
Regarding the raising of the retirement age; your concern, I believe has been addressed in that first, the age will be raised slowly and incrementally, and there will be some sort of consideration given to people in labor intensive jobs.
Regarding Social Security--I just received my first retirement check last month. There hasn't been a cola raise in the last two years anyway. It's really not an important issue for me--a sacrifice I am happy to make.
There are probably a million reasons this plan is not perfect. No plan will be perfect; but this is the best plan I have seen that even has a chance of seeing the light of day in congress.
So, I say do it. Just like health care reform, it's not perfect, but it's a good start and we can make it better in time.
JK
when, has congress ever "fixed" anything, let alone something that big?
It may well have happened, but, I just am not aware.
But,
I do not trust them, to fix or change anything.
I'd rather they do nothing, than, do it wrong and make it worse.